The state of California, known as the Golden State, stands as one of the nineteen states along with the District of Columbia, that mandates the usage of helmets which meet the safety standards prescribed by the federal authorities. The usage of helmets has been proven to be a highly effective measure in reducing fatal injuries incurred by both the operator and passenger of a motorcycle. Nevertheless, it is noteworthy that the number of states enacting compulsory helmet laws has diminished in recent times. This was evidenced by the repeal of a mandatory helmet law by at least one state in 2012. States, such as California, that enforce the use of helmets by all riders and passengers are recognized as "universal helmet law states". In contrast, "partial helmet law states" solely enforce the usage of helmets for riders below a certain age, such as nineteen years old.
Legal Analysis on Motorcycle-Related Injuries and Helmet Laws:
It is a well-established fact that incidents colloquially known as "fender benders" do not exist in the realm of motorcycle accidents. Reports from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) show that a staggering 80% of motorcycle crashes culminate in either death or severe injury of the driver or passenger. In a ten-year observational study of all motorcycle accidents, helmets were found to have saved over 7,400 lives. However, another 6,300 individuals succumbed to injuries sustained in accidents as a result of noncompliance with helmet-wearing protocols.
The justification for implementing helmet laws in California arose from legislative intent to safeguard motorcycle operators and their passengers. It is due to this intention that the statute encompasses motor-driven cycles and motorized bicycles, in addition to motorcycles.
In 1992, the state of California enacted a mandatory helmet law which resulted in a 37% decrease in motorcycle-related fatalities in the subsequent year. Statistical data suggests that the probability of sustaining a head injury in a motorcycle accident drops by 69% in the event of mandatory compliance with helmet-wearing regulations by all riders and passengers.
Legal Framework of the Mandatory Helmet Law in California:
The state of California, pursuant to California Vehicle Code Section 27803, mandates that all motorcycle operators and passengers must wear a helmet while operating a motorcycle, motorized bicycle, or motor-driven cycle. This obligation extends to passengers, whereby it is deemed unlawful for a helmeted passenger to ride alongside a driver who is not adhering to the helmet-wearing requirements. A motorcyclist who is wearing a helmet may still be held in violation of the statute if their passenger is not in compliance with the prescribed helmet laws.
Legal Ramifications of Noncompliance with the Helmet Law:
A controversy arises concerning the appropriate punishment for individuals who breach the regulations stipulated in CA Vehicle Code Section 27803. The California Highway Patrol maintains that individuals violating the law by riding without a helmet may be subjected to a monetary fine, a view that has received the backing of state courts. This standpoint contradicts the opposing perspective that offenders should only be issued with equipment tickets that could be corrected to avoid the payment of a fine.
Legal Standards for Motorcycle Helmet Design Under the Purview of California Law:
The federal government's Department of Transportation imposes minimum safety standards for all motorcycle helmets sold within the United States. Pursuant to the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard 218, prescribed minimum standards include the following helmet features:
In accordance with California helmet laws, motorcyclists and their passengers are required to wear helmets complying with the DOT standards adopted by the state. Attaching GoPro cameras to helmets may result in a legal grey area, as DOT compliance is compromised if the attached item exceeds 5mm in length (refer to https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2011-title49-vol6/pdf/CFR-2011-title49-vol6-sec571-218.pdf).
Legal Requirements for Proper Helmet Use:
California Vehicle Code Section 27803(e) aims to prevent individuals from evading helmet law compliance by wearing the helmet in an unsuitable location on their person. As per the statute, proper helmet use involves wearing the helmet on the individual's head, fastening the chin straps securely to the helmet shell, and ensuring that the helmet fits snugly and limits excessive movement both horizontally and vertically.
Top of Form
Top of Form